The Practice of Wearing Masks in Community Setting According to the Gross National Income During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Rapid Review and Meta-analysis
Main Article Content
Abstract
Several countries have eased public and social restrictions due to declining of positive COVID-19 new cases. This review aimed to quantitatively assess the practice of wearing masks in community settings. Identification and selection of studies in MEDLINE and Google Scholar databases were performed according to PRISMA guidelines. A meta-analysis was performed, and subgroup analysis was based on the country’s gross national income classification. From the twenty-eight studies, the overall estimate of respondents who responded “yes” to whether they wore masks outside the house or in the public area was 64% (95%CI: 48-78). Subgroup analysis showed 28% (95%CI: 5-74), 74% (95%CI: 55-87), 76% (95%CI: 48-92) and 38% (95%CI: 3-93) in High-Income Countries (HIC), Upper-Middle Income Countries (UMIC), Lower Middle-Income Countries (LMIC), and Low-Income Countries (LIC), respectively. We found that the practice of wearing masks in public varies worldwide. Such differences can help future research to identify variations in the natural history of COVID-19 transmission in different regions of the world.
Downloads
Article Details
References
Lightoller GHS. Facial Muscles: The Modiolus and Muscles surrounding the Rima Oris with some remarks about the Panniculus Adiposus1. Journal of anatomy. 1925;60(Pt 1):1.
Schmidt KL, Cohn J. Human facial expressions as adaptations: Evolutionary questions in facial expression research. American Journal of Physical Anthropology. 2001;116(S33):3-24.
Ahn H-J, Cho H-J, Nam Y-S, Han S-H, Chung I-H, Kim I-B. The Location of the Modiolus in Living Korean. Korean Journal of Physical Anthropology. 2013;26(4):141-6.
Al-Hoqail RA, Meguid EMA. An anatomical and analytical study of the modiolus: enlightening its relevance to plastic surgery. Aesthetic plastic surgery. 2009;33(2):147-52.
Yu S-K, Lee M-H, Kim H-S, Park J-T, Kim H-J,
Kim H-J. Histomorphologic approach for the modiolus with reference to reconstructive and aesthetic surgery. Journal of Craniofacial Surgery. 2013;24(4):1414-7.
Çalışkan S, Çelebioğlu EC, Akkaşoğlu S, Beşer CG, Sargon MF. Anatomical and radiological evaluation of modiolus anguli oris in facial anatomy. Journal of Surgery and Medicine. 2019;3(9):694-7.
Pessa JE, Rohrich RJ. Facial topography: clinical anatomy of the face: CRC Press; 2014.
Cannon PR, Schnall S, White M. Transgressions and expressions: Affective facial muscle activity predicts moral judgments. Social psychological and personality science. 2011;2(3):325-31.
Shepherd SV, Lanzilotto M, Ghazanfar AA. Facial muscle coordination in monkeys during rhythmic facial expressions and ingestive movements. Journal of Neuroscience. 2012;32(18):6105-16.
Reissland N, Francis B, Mason J, Lincoln K. Do facial expressions develop before birth? PLoS One. 2011;6(8):e24081.
van Gelder CM, van Capelle CI, Ebbink B, Moor- van Nugteren I, Van den Hout J, Hakkesteegt M, et al. Facial-muscle weakness, speech disorders and dysphagia are common in patients with classic infantile Pompe disease treated with enzyme therapy. Journal of inherited metabolic disease. 2012;35(3):505-11.
Kim MJ, Neta M, Davis FC, Ruberry EJ, Dinescu D, Heatherton TF, et al. Botulinum toxin-induced facial muscle paralysis affects amygdala responses to the perception of emotional expressions: preliminary findings from an ABA design. Biology of mood & anxiety disorders. 2014;4(1):11.
Shimada K, Gasser RF. Variations in the facial muscles at the angle of the mouth. Clinical Anatomy: The Official Journal of the American Association of Clinical Anatomists and the British Association of Clinical Anatomists. 1989;2(3):129- 34.
Sharad J. Lower Face and Neck Indications. Aesthetic Dermatology: Current Perspectives. 2018.
Nakashima M, Lozanoff S. The Face–A Musculoskeletal Perspective. A literature review. Swiss dental journal. 2018;128(9):678-88.
Shim K-S, Hu K-S, Kwak H-H, Youn K-H, Koh K-S, Fontaine C, et al. An anatomical study of the insertion of the zygomaticus major muscle in humans focused on the muscle arrangement at the corner of the mouth. Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 2008;121(2):466-73.
Choi Y-J, Kim J-S, Gil Y-C, Phetudom T, Kim H-J, Tansatit T, et al. Anatomical considerations regarding the location and boundary of the depressor anguli oris muscle with reference to botulinum toxin injection. Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 2014;134(5):917-21.
Kim H-S, Pae C, Bae J-H, Hu K-S, Chang BM, Tansatit T, et al. An anatomical study of the risorius in Asians and its insertion at the modiolus. Surgical and Radiologic Anatomy. 2015;37(2):147-51.
Susan Wainwright P. Langman’s Medical Embryology. Journal of Physical Therapy Education. 2010;24(3):81.
Som P, Naidich T. Illustrated review of the embryology and development of the facial region, part 2: late development of the fetal face and changes in the face from the newborn to adulthood. American Journal of Neuroradiology. 2014;35(1):10-8.
Wehrle T, Kaiser S, editors. Emotion and facial expression. International Workshop on Affective Interactions; 1999: Springer.
Bremhorst A, Sutter NA, Würbel H, Mills DS, Riemer S. Differences in facial expressions during positive anticipation and frustration in dogs awaiting a reward. Scientific reports. 2019;9(1):1- 13.
Vick S-J, Waller BM, Parr LA, Pasqualini MCS, Bard KA. A cross-species comparison of facial morphology and movement in humans and chimpanzees using the facial action coding system (FACS). Journal of nonverbal behavior. 2007;31(1):1-20.
Rosenberg EL, Ekman P. What the face reveals: Basic and applied studies of spontaneous expression using the facial action coding system (FACS): Oxford University Press; 2020.
Burrows AM, Waller BM, Parr LA, Bonar CJ. Muscles of facial expression in the chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes): descriptive, comparative and phylogenetic contexts. Journal of anatomy. 2006;208(2):153-67.
Burrows AM. The facial expression musculature in primates and its evolutionary significance. Bioessays. 2008;30(3):212-25.
Österlund C, Thornell LE, Eriksson PO. Differences in fibre type composition between human masseter and biceps muscles in young and adults reveal unique masseter fibre type growth pattern. The Anatomical Record: Advances in Integrative Anatomy and Evolutionary Biology. 2011;294(7):1158-69.
Kaminski J, Waller BM, Diogo R, Hartstone-Rose A, Burrows AM. Evolution of facial muscle anatomy in dogs. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2019;116(29):14677-81.
Susan S. Gray’s anatomy: the anatomical basis of clinical practice. Elsevier; 2015.
Sinnatamby CS. Last’s Anatomy, International Edition: Regional and Applied: Elsevier Health Sciences; 2011.
Moore KL, Dalley AF. Clinically oriented anatomy: Wolters kluwer india Pvt Ltd; 2018.
Zufferey JA. Importance of the modiolus in plastic surgery. LWW; 2002.
Drake RL, Vogl W, Mitchell AW. Gray’s anatomy for students. Philadelphia: Churchill Livingstone. Elsevier. 2010.
Gassner HG, Rafii A, Young A, Murakami C, Moe KS, Larrabee WF. Surgical anatomy of the face: implications for modern face-lift techniques. Archives of facial plastic surgery. 2008;10(1):9-19.
Rubin LR, Jackson IT. The anatomy of the nasolabial fold: the keystone of the smiling mechanism. Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 1999;103(2):692.
Marinetti CJ-M. The lower muscular balance of the face used to lift labial commissures. Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 1999;104(4):1053-162.
Hinganu MV, Hinganu D, Frîncu LL. Participation of superficial musculo-aponeurotic system of the face in correct dental occlusion. Romanian Journal of Oral Rehabilitation. 2013;5(3):119-24.
Önderoglu S. Topographical relations of the facial artery in the region of the modiolus anguli oris. Okajimas folia anatomica japonica. 1999;76(2- 3):141-7.
Stuzin JM, Wagstrom L, Kawamoto HK, Baker TJ, Wolfe SA. The anatomy and clinical applications of the buccal fat pad. Plastic and reconstructive surgery. 1990;85(1):29-37.
Raja HZ, Saleem MN. Relationship of neutral zone and alveolar ridge with edentulous period. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2010;20(6):395-9.
Cascarini L, Schilling C, Gurney B, Brennan P. Oxford Handbook of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery: Oxford University Press; 2018.
Özkan YK, Evren B, Kauffman A. Anatomical Landmarks and Age-Related Changes in Edentulous Patients. Complete Denture Prosthodontics: Springer; 2018. p. 3-48.
Rangarajan V, Padmanabhan T. Textbook of Prosthodontics-E Book: Elsevier Health Sciences; 2017.
Verma M, Mohanty S, Urs AB, Singh N, Kaur H, Tripathi T, et al. Prosthodontic Treatment For Edentulous Patients Complete Dentures And Implant-Supported Prostheses. Journal of Lasers in Medical Sciences. 2017;8(5):155-9.
Chandra SS. Management of a severely resorbed mandibular ridge with the neutral zone technique. Contemporary clinical dentistry. 2010;1(1):36.
Verma N, Chitre V, Aras M. Enhancing appearance in complete dentures using magnetic retained cheek plumpers. J Indian Prosthodont Soc. 2004;4(2):35-8.
Tong CC, Vandegriend ZP, Lee YH, Lawson W. Anatomical Basis for Lip Reconstruction: The Role of the Modiolus. Annals of plastic surgery. 2019;82(5):565-9.
Baker A. Off-label cosmetic use of botulinum toxin in the lower face. PMFA News. 2015;3(3):30-2.